Overview: Penelope Bourbon, recently acquired by MGP, bridges the gap between sourced and distiller-produced whiskey. The Toasted Series, exemplified by Batch 23-305, showcases their unique approach to finishing. This release, aged for 5 years and bottled at 100 proof, undergoes a secondary maturation in a heavily toasted, char level 2 barrel. While Penelope's distribution in California has been limited, this marks my first opportunity to delve into a full bottle. With its intriguing combination of age, proof, and finishing technique, I'm eager to explore how this bourbon distinguishes itself in a crowded market.
Age: 5 years
Proof: 100 proof (50% ABV)
Mashbill: Not disclosed on the bottle. Website says 75% Corn, 21% Rye, 4% Malted Barley but that is for a different batch (24-301).
Nose: Despite its age and finishing, youthful, grassy notes are surprisingly present. Classic bourbon aromas of cherry and maple syrup intertwine with burnt sugar and smokiness. A touch of heat and spice, perhaps cinnamon or rye-derived, adds complexity.
Palate: The early and mid-palate shine with vanilla, cherry, brown sugar, black pepper, and cinnamon. However, these flavors seem somewhat disjointed, lacking a cohesive integration. Additional aging, either in the primary or finishing barrel, might have harmonized these elements.
Finish: The finish is bright and slightly sharp, showcasing prominent oak influence. It leans towards burnt and smoky rather than sweet and smooth, with a hint of toasted marshmallow sweetness.
Final Thoughts: While I had high hopes for this bourbon, it falls a bit short of expectations. It's a decent pour but lacks the wow factor, especially considering its price point (above $50). In this range, numerous other bottles offer a more compelling experience.
This isn't a bad bourbon by any means, but for a 5-year, 100-proof, toasted expression, it doesn't quite hit the mark for me. It's worth trying, as it might resonate with others differently. However, it simply doesn't fit my personal preference.
Rating: Bottom Shelf - Link to ratings explanations
No comments:
Post a Comment